Independent Boards and Innovation

Journal of Financial Economics 123 (2017), 536–557

Summary

Question. Independent boards are thought to reduce agency costs. Do they also change what kind of innovation a firm pursues?

Approach. Patent data around regulatory changes that required firms to adopt independent boards, comparing the technological focus and citation profile of their patents before and after.

Finding. Firms that transition to independent boards focus on more crowded and familiar technology areas. They patent and claim more and receive more citations overall, but the gain comes from incremental patents in the middle of the citation distribution; the numbers of uncited and highly cited patents, the marks of riskier exploration, do not change significantly.

Why it matters. Closer monitoring raises measurable output but steers firms toward exploitation. Governance reforms that look good on patent counts can quietly narrow a firm's search.

Abstract

Much research has suggested that independent boards of directors are more effective in reducing agency costs and improving firm governance. How they influence innovation is less clear. Relying on regulatory changes, we show that firms that transition to independent boards focus on more crowded and familiar areas of technology. They patent and claim more and receive more total future citations to their patents. However, the citation increase comes mainly from incremental patents in the middle of the citation distribution; the numbers of uncited and highly cited patents—arguably associated with riskier innovation strategies—do not change significantly.

How to cite

Balsmeier, Benjamin, Lee Fleming, and Gustavo Manso (2017). Independent Boards and Innovation. Journal of Financial Economics 123, 536–557.

@article{balsmeier2017independent,
  author = {Balsmeier, Benjamin and Fleming, Lee and Manso, Gustavo},
  title = {Independent Boards and Innovation},
  journal = {Journal of Financial Economics},
  volume = {123},
  number = {3},
  pages = {536–557},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jfineco.2016.12.005}
}